December 18-21, 2025 – Christmas in Mistletoe Falls 3: The Chrismurdering Digital Program

Thank You to our Sponsors!

Cast (in Order of Appearance)

Travis Harold Coles as Santa Claus

Hannah Dodson as Mary Christmas

Chris Stanley as Dash Ingtrudasno

Molly Alexander as Mrs. Claus

Bailey Connor as Mayor Joy Tudaworlt

Thomas Houston as Dr. Bob Tailsring

Dino Larumbe as Oletta Townnabetlehem

Cami Nicole Hall as December Twennyfith

Patrick Balbo as Wynn Terwunerlan

Gwen Leahy as Sugar Plum

Mark Poticny as Jack Frost

Ethan Goble as Tinsel Washington

Treyla Trash as Detective Felice Navidad

Written and Directed by

Rick Garman

Sound Operation

Lukas Evans

Lighting Design & Operation

Toria Nicole Shaw

Set Design & Construction

Travis Harold Coles

Photographer

Travis Spangenburg

Don’t Miss Our Murderously Merry Cocktails!

Songs

Act 1

A Jazzy Christmas (Ensemble)
Deck the Halls
Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer
Little Drummer Boy
12 Days of Christmas
Jingle Bells
Joy to the World
Info about these songs.

Here Comes Santa Claus (Santa Claus)
As performed by Elvis Presley

I Think He Was Really Murdered (Sugar Plum, Jack Frost, Tinsel Washington)
To the tune of We Wish You a Merry Christmas. Parody lyrics by Rick Garman.

Santa Claus is Coming to Town (Dash Ingtrudasno)
As performed by Justin Bieber.

Cool Yule (Detective Felice Navidad)
As performed by Bette Midler.

Mele Kalikimaka (Dr. Bob Tailsring and December Twennyfith)
As performed by Bette Midler.

Sleigh Ride (Oletta Townnabetlehem and Wynn Terwunerlan)
As performed by The Ronettes.

Baby, It’s Homicide (Sugar Plum, Jack Frost, Tinsel Washington)
To the tune of Baby, It’s Cold Outside. Parody lyrics by Rick Garman.

The Christmas Blues (Mrs. Claus)
As performed by Dean Martin.

Santa Baby (Dash, Wynn, Tinsel, Bob, Jack, Santa)
As performed by Kelly Clarkson.

This Christmas (December Twennyfith)
As performed by Jess Glynne.

What Christmas Means to Me (Mayor Joy Tudaworlt)
As performed by Stevie Wonder.

Felix Navidad (Sugar Plum, Jack Frost, Tinsel Washington)
To the tune of Feliz Navidad by Jose Feliciano. Parody lyrics by Rick Garman.

A Rockin’ Christmas (Ensemble)
Jingle Bell Rock as performed by Brian Setzer
Everybody’s Waiting for the Man with the Bag as performed by Brian Setzer
Rockin’ Around the Christmas Tree as performed by Brian Setzer
Dig That Crazy Santa Claus as performed by Brian Setzer
Run, Run Rudolph as performed by Kelly Clarkson

Act 2

We Need a Little Clue Right Now (Sugar Plum, Jack Frost, Tinsel Washington)
As performed by Angela Lansbury in Mame. Parody lyrics by Rick Garman

Winter Wonderland/Let It Snow! (Detective Felice Navidad and Mayor Joy Tudaworlt)
As performed by Bette Midler and Johnny Mathis.

Blue Christmas (Mary Christmas)
As performed by Celine Dion.

Happy Holidays/Holiday Season (Oletta Townnabetlehem)
As performed by Andy Williams.

All the Jingle Ladies (Sugar Plum, Jack Frost, Tinsel Washington)
To the tune of All the Single Ladies by Beyonce. Parody lyrics by Rick Garman.

I’ll Be Home for Christmas (Santa Claus and Mrs. Claus)
As performed by Mel Torme.

Holly Jolly Christmas (Dr. Bob Tailsring)
As performed by Michael Buble.

It’s Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas (Wynn Terwunerlan)
As performed by Kelly Clarkson.

Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas (Mary, Joy, Oletta, December, Sugar, Mrs. Claus)
As performed by TBD.

Defiling Christmas Trees (Sugar Plum, Jack Frost, Tinsel Washington)
To the tune of Defying Gravity from Wicked. Parody lyrics by Rick Garman.

White Christmas (Mary Christmas and Dash Ingtrudasno)
As performed by Michael Buble and Shania Twain.

A Suprise Christmas Killer Song (The Killer)
Parody lyrics by Rick Garman.

All I Want for Christmas is You (Ensemble)
As performed by Mariah Carey.

The Christmas Song (Ensemble)
As performed by Nat “King” Cole.

The Most Wonderful Time of the Year (Ensemble)
As performed by Andy Williams.

The Cast (in alphabetical order)

Molly Alexander as Mrs. Claus

Molly Alexander is a STEM-major sort of person who has been successfully infiltrating the musical and theatrical world for years. One day, the people in charge will realize that she has degrees in Wildlife and Veterinary Technology and never actually studied the arts, but they haven’t wised up yet so she keeps getting away with it. She has sung a capella with The Ecotones, presented the Bard’s works with Savannah Shakes, gotten weird with Odd Lot Improv, and voice acted for various audio dramas. She also moonlights in stage management because there is nothing quite like a color-coded spreadsheet. Now she is delighted to be on stage with the Savannah Cabaret!

Patrick Balbo as Wynn Terwunerlan

Patrick “Paddy” Balbo is a Savannah native and a current Theater major at Dartmouth College. He began his acting career with Savannah Children’s Theatre, where he played such distinguished roles as the “guy who holds up a mirror” in Frozen Jr. Paddy continued performing at Benedictine Military School, starring in several productions including Ren McCormack in Footloose and Prince Topher in Cinderella. You may have last seen him this summer as Joey in Murdered by the Millennium. Paddy is thrilled to be back with Savannah Cabaret and would like to wish everyone a very Merry Christmas! @paddy_balbo

Travis Harold Coles as Santa Claus

Travis Coles has been involved in theatre in Savannah for over 18 years. As Executive Producer of the Bay Street Theatre, Travis has been involved with some of Savannah’s most exciting community theatre productions, such as Cabaret, Chicago, Avenue Q, Sweeney Todd, Rocky Horror, and many more. Travis was also a member of the Collective Face Theatre Ensemble, performing in Gatsby, Calendar Girls, Big Love, and Jesus Christ Superstar, among others. Travis loves being a Savannah Cabaret regular, and has enjoyed directing and performing in a variety of productions with Sav Cab. When not managing Club One or serving on the Savannah-Chatham Metropolitan Planning Commission, Travis enjoys helping people buy or sell property as an agent with Keller Williams Realty. In his free time Coles enjoys sleeping. What Coles wants most is to be Rick Garman when he grows up. Enjoy the show!

Bailey Connor as Mayor Joy Tudaworlt

A Savannah native, Bailey began performing at a young age in and around the Savannah area. Once she graduated from high school, her passion for performing drove her to enroll as a student at Sarah Lawrence College in New York where she graduated with a Bachelors of Arts. While in college, Bailey also studied at the British American Drama Academy in London. Recent credits include Christmas in Mistletoe Falls 2 (Mayor Joy Tudaworlt), Grease (Jan), and Hairspray (Tracy Turnblad). Bailey is ecstatic to perform with the incredibly talented artists and the amazing crew of The Savannah Cabaret!

Hannah Dodson as Mary Christmas

Hannah Dodson is a local vocalist, actress, and owner of Itsy Bitsy Princess Parties. You can also catch her as her drag alter ego, Mighta Chondra with Club One Cabaret. As a long time member of the Savannah Cabaret, Hannah is so thankful to continue to perform on the Club One stage with this crew! Some of her most recent credits include Rocky Horror Show Live! (Janet, Magenta, Columbia), Grease (The Savannah Theatre), Elf: The Musical (The Savannah Theatre), and too many Savannah Cabaret productions to count!

Ethan Goble as Tinsel Washington

Ethan is so excited to be back performing with the Savannah Cabaret. He recently earned his BA in theatre from Georgia Southern University. Some of his recent acting credits include Eurydice (GSU), Rocky Horror Show Live (Bay Street Theatre), Young Frankenstein (Savannah Cabaret), and various other shows with the Savannah Cabaret. In addition to acting, he has also contributed his technical skills to Master Class (Collective Face) and Spitfire Grill (Savannah Repertory Theatre) among others. When he’s not working on shows, Ethan can be found performing as a DJ at Club One.

Cami Nicole Hall as December Twennyfith

Cami Nicole Hall (she/her) was raised in rural Indiana and has been a musical theatre nerd since birth (just ask her mom). As a member of The Savannah Cabaret for the last four years, you may recognize her from the reprising role of Ginger in The Time Traveling Drag Queens series, roller skating in Murdered by Disco, or that epic air drum solo in Murdered by Horror. This Hoosier has been in the peach state for over a decade: paralegal lead by day, sound engineer and actor by night. When Cami isn’t on- or backstage, you can find her watching wild birds with her wife and taking too many pictures of their dogs.

Thomas Houston as Dr. Bob Tailsring

A native Savannahian, Thomas has worn many hats as an actor, author, playwright, composer and comedian. He also wears actual hats.

Dino Larumbe as Oletta Townnabetlehem

Originally from Venezuela, Dino Larumbe studied Music Education in Choral Studies. They have been performing in Savannah for over two years in productions such as The Bay Street Theater’s Rocky Horror Show Live and as Jane Doe in Georgia Southern University’s production of Ride the Cyclone. The Savannah Cabaret returnee and local theater enthusiast is excited to be back on stage!

Gwen Leahy as Sugar Plum

Gwen Leahy is thrilled to be carrying on the now long-standing Savannah Cabaret tradition of playing “all of the extras” (see also: the rest of the “Christmas in Mistletoe Falls” series and the “Murdered By” series). Gwen Leahy has been in almost every single one of Savannah Cabaret’s more than 30 productions, usually on stage but sometimes behind the scenes. They also are a regular participant in The Bay Street Theatre’s yearly production of The Rocky Horror Show LIVE!, with their most recent role being Eddie (shhhhhh!) Gwen is a long-standing advocate for the Savannah theatre and performance community, especially concerning the melting pot of diversity it has become, and wishes to highlight the incredible talent it possesses by way of the hundreds of POC and LGBTQ+ actors who are the backbone of our theatre family; without them, there would be no us.

Mark Poticny as Jack Frost

Mark Poticny is Savannah native with vast experience as a musician, singer/song writer, and percussionist for more than 20 years! He has performed at several establishments in Savannah both on stage with a band and behind the scenes at various local theaters! This is his 5th show with The Savannah Cabaret and is simply thrilled to be joining in on the fun he’ll be sharing with his stage family.

Chris Stanley as Dash Ingtrudasno

Christopher Stanley is so excited to reprise his role as Dash in this third installment of Mistletoe Falls. Chris has been part of Savannah’s vibrant theatre community since moving to the city in 2000 to attend SCAD. Some of his favorite roles have been Roger (RENT – 2012), Mendel (Falsettos – 2013), Claude Bukowski (Hair – 2019), and Rocky (The Rocky Horror Show – 2024). As a singer/songwriter, he performs under the name Topher Cronin. Aside from theatre, he is a crazy cat man with five felines: Ninja, Acorn, Ivy, Eleanor Rigby, and Rocky Raccoon.

Treyla Trash as Detective Felice Navidad

Trey Norris is happy to be back on stage in this chapter of “things Rick Garman convinces me is a good idea.” A native to Savannah, Trey is an active member of The Bay Street Theatre and Savannah Cabaret. You may have seen him recently directing Bay Street Theatre’s Rocky Horror Show Live or playing Lucifer in the world premiere of Lucifer’s Law: a dark comedy musical. Trey’s other roles include Jonathan Larson in Tick, Tick …BOOM!, Christopher Boone in Curious Incident of the Dog in the Nighttime, and Imma Slappabitch in Savannah Cabaret’s Time Traveling Drag Queens series. Trey’s passions include reading, cooking, and have the gay audacity to take on any task.

The Creative Team and Crew

Written & Directed by Rick Garman

Rick Garman grew up in Iowa but moved to Los Angeles as soon as he was old enough to be sure that his parents couldn’t send a sheriff to bring him back. He studied theater at the American Academy of Dramatic Arts and made his writing debut with a stage production 17 Days which was produced in Los Angeles and in small theaters around the country. His second play Mountains won the GLAAD Media Award for Outstanding Los Angeles Theater Production. Rick has written more than 40 movies for the Hallmark Channel and other networks including Christmas on Cherry Lane with Jonathan Bennett, Catherine Bell, and James Denton; A Shoe Addict’s Christmas starring Candace Cameron Bure, Luke Macfarlane, and Jean Smart; and The Groomsmen: Second Chances which won the GLAAD Media Award in 2025 for Outstanding TV Movie, Cable or Streaming. He currently resides in Savannah and is thrilled to be producing the Savannah Cabaret. His latest Christmas movie, Oy to the World, debuted December 14, 2025 and is currently playing on Hallmark Channel (check schedule) and Hallmark+.

Sound Operator: Lukas Evans

Lukas Evans is a Savannah, Georgia native who has spent the last three years happily hiding behind the scenes with local theater companies. They usually work with lights and stage handling, but this show marks their brave first adventure on the sound board. Past credits include The Rocky Horror Picture Show (Live), Young Frankenstein, and A Gentleman’s Guide to Love & Murder with groups such as Savannah Cabaret and Bay Street Theatre. When not making things light up (or hopefully sound right), they’re excited to keep learning and supporting Savannah’s theater scene.

Lighting Design and Operation: Toria Nicole Shaw

Toria is a Savannah native with a love of theatre. If you’re lucky, you can catch her onstage, othertimes she shining a light on the show.

Photographer: Travis Spangenburg

Travis Spangenburg (Photographer) is thrilled to shoot his 7th show with Savannah Cabaret. A lifelong fan of Mel Brooks, he’s excited to get YOU excited with photos of this wonderful cast. Follow @travis.spange.photo for shots of theatre, drag, princesses, and more!

UPCOMING SAVANNAH CABARET SHOWS

Join our mailing list and follow us on Facebook to get updates and exclusive offers!

UPCOMING LIVE THEATER IN SAVANNAH

Visit OnStageSavannah.com for all of the current listings.

December 18-21, 2025 – Christmas in Mistletoe Falls 3: The Chrismurdering Digital Program

Thank You to our Sponsors!

Cast (in Order of Appearance)

Travis Harold Coles as Santa Claus

Hannah Dodson as Mary Christmas

Chris Stanley as Dash Ingtrudasno

Molly Alexander as Mrs. Claus

Bailey Connor as Mayor Joy Tudaworlt

Thomas Houston as Dr. Bob Tailsring

Dino Larumbe as Oletta Townnabetlehem

Cami Nicole Hall as December Twennyfith

Patrick Balbo as Wynn Terwunerlan

Gwen Leahy as Sugar Plum

Mark Poticny as Jack Frost

Ethan Goble as Tinsel Washington

Treyla Trash as Detective Felice Navidad

Written and Directed by

Rick Garman

Sound Operation

Lukas Evans

Lighting Design & Operation

Toria Nicole Shaw

Set Design & Construction

Travis Harold Coles

Photographer

Travis Spangenburg

Don’t Miss Our Murderously Merry Cocktails!

Songs

Act 1

Act 2

The Cast (in alphabetical order)

Molly Alexander as Mrs. Claus

Patrick Balbo as Wynn Terwunerlan

Travis Harold Coles as Santa Claus

Bailey Connor as Mayor Joy Tudaworlt

Hannah Dodson as Mary Christmas

Ethan Goble as Tinsel Washington

Cami Nicole Hall as December Twennyfith

Thomas Houston as Dr. Bob Tailsring

Dino Larumbe as Oletta Townnabetlehem

Gwen Leahy as Sugar Plum

Mark Poticny as Jack Frost

Chris Stanley as Dash Ingtrudasno

Treyla Trash as Detective Felice Navidad

The Creative Team and Crew

Written & Directed by Rick Garman

Sound Operator: Lukas Evans

Lighting Design and Operation: Toria Nicole Shaw

Photographer: Travis Spangenburg

UPCOMING SAVANNAH CABARET SHOWS

The People vs. Broadway

Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1970s

Murdered by Y2K

Christmas in Mistletoe Falls 4: The Chrismarrying

UPCOMING LIVE THEATER IN SAVANNAH