Song Library
| SONG | BY | SHOW | SINGER(S) | SUNG WITH |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12 Days of Christmas | Jazz Version | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Ensemble | |
| 100 Easy Ways | Wonderful Town | Murder at the Bay Street Cabaret | Gwen Leahy | |
| A Nightingale Sang in Berkeley Square | Manhattan Transfer | Love Stories/Love Songs | Ensemble | |
| Against All Odds | Glee | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Damon Banks Jr. | |
| All About that Bass | Postmodern Jukebox | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! | Dani Vazquez Sallie Just Sallie Magnolia Minxxx | Sallie and Magnolia |
| All I Ask | Adele | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Taylor Mercier | |
| All I Care About | Chicago | Bawdy Burlesque | Val Lavelle | |
| All I Want for Christmas is You | Mariah Carey | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Ensemble | |
| All of Me | John Legend | Love Stories/Love Songs | Daniel Hilton/Sallie Just Sallie | |
| All of Me | Postmodern Jukebox | HSF Event | Drew Hillis | |
| All That Jazz | Chicago | Hot Summer Broadway The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret Underground: Basement Broadway 1-17-23 | Cecilia Tran Arango Gwen Leahy Hannah Dodson | |
| Always Look on the Bright Side of Life | Spamalot | Showstoppers | Ensemble | |
| Anything Goes | Tony Bennett & Lady Gaga | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! | Travis Cheek | |
| Anything You Can Do | Annie Get Your Gun | Showstoppers | JoJo Ward/Carman iCandy Trey Norris/Treyla Trash | Treyla |
| As if We Never Said Goodbye | Sunset Boulevard | Underground: Basement Broadway 1-17-23 | Trey Norris | |
| As Time Goes By | Natalie Cole | Love Stories/Love Songs | Hannah Dodson | |
| At Last | Etta James | Love Stories/Love Songs | Gwen Leahy | |
| At Last | Etta James | Underground: Standards 1-24-23 | Hannah Dodson | |
| Baby Mine | Bette Midler | Underground: Bette Midler 1-31-23 | Gwen Leahy | |
| Baby, It's Cold Outside | Idina Menzel & Michael Buble | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! | Justin Kent Gwen Leahy | Gwen |
| Bad Idea | Waitress | Hot Summer Broadway | Justin Kent Taylor Mercier | Taylor |
| Be Our Guest | Beauty & the Beast | Murder at the Bay Street Cabaret | Cami Nicole Hall | |
| Being Alive | Company | Award-Winning Broadway Underground: Basement Broadway 1-17-23 | Rick Garman Trey Norris | |
| Better with a Man | A Gentleman's Guide to Love & Murder | Murder at the Bay Street Cabaret | Rayshawn Roberts | |
| Big Blond and Beautiful | Hairspray | Hot Summer Broadway | JoJo Ward/Carman iCandy | |
| Big Spender | Sweet Charity | Hot Summer Broadway | Cecilia Tran Arango Carman iCandy Taylor Mercier | Carman and Taylor |
| Black Hole Sun | Postmodern Jukebox | HSF Event | Cecilia Tran Arango | |
| Blank Space | Postmodern Jukebox | HSF Event | Chris Stanley | |
| Blue Skies | Irving Berlin | Underground: Standards 1-24-23 | Hannah Dodson | |
| Boogie Woogie Bugle Boy | Bette Midler | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! | Daniel Hilton/Sallie Just Sallie Kevin Hincapie/Christie Creme Trey Norris/Treyla Trash | Kevin & Treyla |
| Born This Way | Lady Gaga (Piano Version) | Say Gay | Cami Nicole Hall | |
| Brave | Sara Bareilles | Say Gay | Gwen Leahy | |
| Breakin' Up is Hard to Do (slow version) | Neil Sedaka | Underground: Standards 1-24-23 Love Stories/Love Songs | Rick Garman Brandon Kaufman | |
| Breathe | In the Heights | Award-Winnng Broadway | Dani Vazquez | |
| Bring on the Men | Jekyl and Hyde | Bawdy Burlesque | Gwen Leahy, Hannah Dodson | Hannah |
| Broadway Baby | Follies | Bawdy Burlesque | Trey Norris/Treyla Trash | |
| Burn | Hamilton | Hot Summer Broadway The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret Underground: Basement Broadway 1-17-23 | Taylor Mercier Carrie Kitchen | |
| Cabaret | Cabaret | Showstoppers | Hannah Dodson | |
| Came Here for Love (Acoustic) | Sigala w/Ella Eyre | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Rick Garman | |
| Can't Buy Me Love | Ella Fitzgerald | HSF Event | Val Lavelle | |
| Can't Help Falling in Love | Pentatonix | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Ensemble | |
| Careless Whisper | Postmodern Jukebox | HSF Event | Val Lavelle | |
| Cell Block Tango | Chicago | Murder at the Bay Street Cabaret | Ensemble | |
| Cheek to Cheek | Frank Sinatra | Underground: Rat Pack 2-28-23 | Valerie America Lavelle | |
| Christmas Baby Please Come Home | Dusty Springfield | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! | Ensemble | |
| Christmas Waltz | Kristin Chenoweth | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! | Val Lavelle | |
| Come Rain or Come Shine | Billie Holliday | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! Underground: Rat Pack 2-28-23 | Magnolia Minxxx Valerie America Lavelle | |
| Criminal | Postmodern Jukebox | HSF Event | Cecilia Tran Arango | |
| Dancing On My Own | Calum Scott | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Rick Garman | |
| Defying Gravity | Wicked | Showstoppers | JoJo Ward/Carman iCandy Gwen Leahy | Gwen |
| Do You Wanna Dance? | Bette Midler | Say Gay | Trey Norris/Treyla Trash | |
| Don't Know Much | Aaron Neville & Linda Ronstadt | Love Stories/Love Songs | Daniel Hilton/Sallie Just Sallie Gwen Leahy | Gwen |
| Don't Let the Sun Go Down on Me | Elton John | Say Gay | Justin Kent | |
| Don't Rain on my Parade | Funny Girl | Say Gay The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Gwen Leahy Dani Vazquez | |
| Dream a Little Dream | Ella Fitzgerald | Underground: Standards 1-24-23 | Hannah Dodson | |
| Endless Love | Diana Ross & Lionel Richie | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Rick Garman Trey Norris | Trey Norris |
| Ex's and Oh's | Postmodern Jukebox | HSF Event | Hannah Dodson | |
| Fly Me to the Moon | Frank Sinatra | Underground: Standards 1-24-23 Underground: Rat Pack 2-28-23 | Travis Harold Coles Damon Banks Jr. | |
| For Forever | Dear Evan Hansen | Say Gay Say Gay! Louder! The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Rick Garman | Travis |
| For Now | Avenue Q | Award-Winnng Broadway | Ensemble | |
| Friends | Bette Midler | Underground: Bette Midler 1-31-23 | Ensemble | |
| From a Distance | Bette Midler | Underground: Bette Midler 1-31-23 | Trey Norris | |
| Glory of Love | Bette Midler | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Trey Norris | |
| Glory of Love | Johnny Mercer | Underground: Standards 1-24-23 | Andrew Hillis | |
| God Only Knows | Joss Stone | Love Stories/Love Songs | Dani Vazquez | |
| Good as Hell | Lizzo | Say Gay The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Travis Cheek | |
| Good Morning Baltimore | Hairspray | Bawdy Burlesque The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Trey Norris/Treyla Trash Travis Cheek | |
| Happily Ever After | Once Upon a Mattress | Underground: Basement Broadway 2-21-23 | Valerie America Lavelle | |
| Happy Days Are Here Again | Barbra Streisand | Underground: Standards 1-24-23 | Rick Garman | |
| Happy Days Are Here Again/Get Happy | Barbra Streisand & Judy Garland | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Trey Norris Cami Nicole Hall | Treyla Trash |
| Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas | Ella Fitzgerald | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! | Richie Cook | |
| Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas | Sam Smith | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Taylor Mercier | |
| He Vas My Boyfriend | Young Frankenstein | Murder at the Bay Street Cabaret | Rayshawn Roberts | |
| Holly Jolly Christmas | Michael Buble | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Travis Harold Coles Trey Norris/Treyla Trash | Trey Norris/Treyla Trash |
| Home | The Wiz | Showstoppers | Daniel Hilton/Sallie Just Sallie | |
| Hot Stuff | Donna Summer Show | Hot Summer Broadway | JoJo Ward/Carman iCandy Trey Norris/Treyla Trash | Treyla |
| How Will I Know | Sam Smith | Love Stories/Love Songs | Gwen Leahy | |
| I Am What I Am | La Cage aux Folles | Say Gay | Trey Norris/Treyla Trash | |
| I Cain't Say No | Oklahoma | Underground: Basement Broadway 1-17-23 | Hannah Dodson | |
| I Can't Make You Love Me | George Michael | Love Stories/Love Songs | Taylor Mercier | |
| I Don't Want to Miss a Thing | Postmodern Jukebox | HSF Event | Val Lavelle | |
| I Don't Want to Miss a Thing (Acoustic) | Aerosmith | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Daniel J. Hilton | |
| I Kissed a Girl | Postmodern Jukebox | HSF Event | Gwen Leahy | |
| I Only Have Eyes for You | Ella Fitzgerald | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! | Kevin Hincapie/Christie Creme | |
| I Put My Hand In | Bette Midler/Hello Dolly! | Underground: Bette Midler 1-31-23 | Joey Timmons | |
| I Think It's Going to Rain Today | Bette Midler | Underground: Bette Midler 1-31-23 | Trey Norris | |
| I Try | Macy Gray | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Carrie Kitchen | |
| I Want to Be Loved by You | Marilyn Monroe | Underground: Rat Pack 2-28-23 | Hannah Dodson | |
| I Will Always Love You | Boyce Avenue | Love Stories/Love Songs | Richie Cook | |
| I'd Rather Be Me | Mean Girls | Underground: Basement Broadway 1-17-23 | Carrie Kitchen | |
| I'll Be Home for Christmas | Bing Crosby | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! | Travis Coles | |
| I'll Be Home for Christmas | Bette Midler | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Trey Norris/Treyla Trash | |
| I'll Be Seeing You | Billie Holliday | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! | Hannah Dodson | |
| I'm Coming Out | Diana Ross | Say Gay | Magnolia Minxxx | |
| I'm Getting Nuttin' For Christmas | Shirley Temple | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! | JoJo Ward/Carman iCandy | |
| I'm Still Here | Follies | Murder at the Bay Street Cabaret | Val Lavelle | |
| I'm the Only One | Melissa Etheridge | Say Gay | Cami Nicole Hall | |
| I've Got the World on a String | Michael Buble | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! | Travis Cheek | |
| If I Ain't Got You | Alicia Keys | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Hannah Dodson | |
| If That's Your Boyfriend | Meshell Ndegeocello | Say Gay | Magnolia Minxxx | |
| If You've Got It (Flaunt It) | The Producers | Bawdy Burlesque | Taylor Mercier | |
| Impossible Dream | Man of La Mancha | Underground: Basement Broadway 2-21-23 | Justin P. Kent | |
| In His Eyes | Jekyll & Hyde | Underground: Basement Broadway 2-21-23 | Andrew Hillis | |
| In Short | Edges | Murder at the Bay Street Cabaret The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Rick Garman Chris Stanley | |
| In the Mood | Bette Midler | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! | Ensemble | |
| In Your Eyes | Peter Gabriel | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Mark Poticny | |
| It Don't Mean a Thing | Tony Bennett & Lady Gaga | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! | Kevin Hincapie/Christie Creme | |
| It Had to be You | Harry Connick Jr. | Love Stories/Love Songs | Richie Cook | |
| It Sucks to be Me (Parody) | Avenue Q | Murder at the Bay Street Cabaret | Ensemble | |
| It Takes Two | Hairspray | Underground: Basement Broadway 2-21-23 | Ethan Goble | |
| It's Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas | Michael Buble | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! | Daniel Hilton/Sallie Just Sallie Valerie America Lavelle | Val |
| It's the Most Wonderful Time of the Year | Andy Williams | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Ensemble | |
| Jingle Bell Battle | Various | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Ensemble | |
| Jingle Bell Rock | Brian Setzer Orchestra | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Justin P. Kent | |
| Joy to the World | Aretha Franklin | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Taylor Mercier Daniel J. Hilton/Sallie Just Sallie Valerie America Lavelle Hannah Dodson Trey Norris/Treyla Trash Gwen Leahy | Daniel/Sallie, Val, Hannah, Gwen, Trey/Treyla |
| Just the Way You Are (Acoustic) | Bruno Mars | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Mark Poticny | |
| L-O-V-E | Nat "King" Cole | Underground: Rat Pack 2-28-23 | Hannah Dodson | |
| La Vie en Rose | Bette Midler | Underground: Bette Midler 1-31-23 | Gwen Leahy | |
| Ladies Who Lunch | Company | Showstoppers | Trey Norris/Treyla Trash | |
| Last Christmas | Christmas | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! | Gwen Leahy | |
| Let it Snow | Harry Connick Jr. | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Daniel J. Hilton/Sallie Just Sallie | Travis Cheek |
| Let it Snow | Harry Connick Jr. | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Travis Cheek | Daniel J. Hilton/Sallie Just Sallie |
| Levitating | Postmodern Jukebox | HSF Event | Taylor Mercier | |
| Like I'm Gonna Lose You | Meghan Trainor & John Legend | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Hannah Dodson | Daniel J. Hilton |
| Like I'm Gonna Lose You | Meghan Trainor & John Legend | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Daniel J. Hilton | Hannah Dodson |
| Little Girls | Annie | Award-Winnng Broadway | Gwen Leahy | |
| Little Girls | Annie | The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Gwen Leahy | |
| Love Shack | The B-52s | Say Gay | Gwen Leahy | Hannah & Justin |
| Love Shack | The B-52s | Say Gay | Hannah Dodson | Gwen & Justin |
| Love Shack | The B-52s | Say Gay | Justin Kent | Gwen & Hannah |
| Love Shack | The-B52s | The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Justin P. Kent | Hannah, Gwen |
| Love Shack | The-B52s | The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Hannah Dodson | Gwen, Justin |
| Love Shack | The-B52s | The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Gwen, Leahy | Hannah, Justin |
| Luck be a Lady | Guys and Dolls | Murder at the Bay Street Cabaret | DJ Banks Jr. | |
| Luck be a Lady | Guys and Dolls | Underground: Basement Broadway 1-17-23 | Damon Banks Jr. | |
| Mambo Italiano | Dean Martin | Underground: Rat Pack 2-28-23 | Trey Norris | |
| Maybe This Time | Cabaret | Award-Winnng Broadway | Hannah Dodson | |
| Merry Christmas Baby | Christina Aguilera | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Hannah Dodson | |
| Merry Christmas Darling | Carpenters | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! | Chris Stanley | |
| Minnie the Moocher | Cab Calloway | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! | Hannah Dodson | Christie and Travis Cheek |
| Minnie the Moocher | Cab Calloway | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! | Kevin Hincapie/Christie Creme | Hannah and Travis Cheek |
| Minnie the Moocher | Cab Calloway | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! | Travis Cheek | Christie and Hannah |
| Miss Otis Regrets | Bette Midler | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! | Cami Nicole Hall | |
| Miss Otis Regrets | Bette Midler | The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Trey Norris | |
| Miss Otis Regrets | Bette Midler | Underground: Bette Midler 1-31-23 | Gwen Leahy | |
| MMMBop | Postmodern Jukebox | HSF Event | Cami Nicole Hall | |
| Money, Money | Cabaret | Murder at the Bay Street Cabaret | Daniel Hilton/Sallie Just Sallie | Gwen |
| Money, Money | Cabaret | Murder at the Bay Street Cabaret | Gwen Leahy | Sallie |
| Mr. Brightside | Postmodern Jukebox | HSF Event | Gwen Leahy | |
| Mrs. Claus is Back in Town | Brian Setzer Orchestra | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Valerie America Lavelle | |
| My Heart Will Go On | Postmodern Jukebox | HSF Event | Cami Nicole Hall | |
| My Way | Frank Sinatra | Underground: Rat Pack 2-28-23 | Damon Banks Jr. | |
| New York, New York | Frank Sinatra | Underground: Rat Pack 2-28-23 | Travis Harold Coles | |
| No Matter What | Calum Scott | Say Gay | Travis Coles | |
| Not Getting Married | Company | Hot Summer Broadway | Trey Norris/Treyla Trash | |
| Nothing Compares 2U | Prince & Rosie Gaines | Love Stories/Love Songs | Brandon Kaufman, Richie Cook | Richie Cooke |
| Nothing Compares 2U | Prince & Rosie Gaines | Love Stories/Love Songs | Richie Cook | Brandon |
| Nothing Compares 2U | Prince/Rosie Gaines | The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Rick Garman | Hannah Dodson |
| Nothing Compares 2U | Prince/Rosie Gaines | The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Hannah Dodson | Rick Garman |
| O Holy Night | Boyce Avenue | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Taylor Mercier | Andrew Hillis |
| O Holy Night | Boyce Avenue | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Andrew Hillis | Taylor Mercier |
| One for my Baby | Bette Midler | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! | Cami Nicole Hall | |
| Only Us | Dear Evan Hansen | Underground: Basement Broadway 1-17-23 | Carrie Kitchen | Damon Banks Jr. |
| Only Us | Dear Evan Hansen | Underground: Basement Broadway 1-17-23 | Damon Banks Jr. | Carrie Kitchen |
| Oops...I Did it Again | Postmodern Jukebox | HSF Event | Taylor Mercier | |
| Open Arms | Journey | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Damon Banks Jr. | |
| Out Tonight | Rent | Showstoppers | JoJo Ward/Carman iCandy | |
| Pardon My Southern Accent | Johnny Mercer | Underground: Standards 1-24-23 | Andrew Hillis | |
| Please Come Home for Christmas | Kelly Clarkson | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! | Trey Norris/Treyla Trash | |
| Please Don't Touch Me | Young Frankenstein | Murder at the Bay Street Cabaret | JoJo Ward/Carman iCandy | |
| Rewrite the Stars | Zac Efron & Zendaya | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Taylor Mercier | Mark Poticny |
| Rewrite the Stars | Zac Efron & Zendaya | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Mark Poticny | Taylor Mercier |
| Rise Up | Andra Day | Say Gay | Taylor Mercier | |
| Roar | Katy Perry (Acoustic) | Say Gay | Hannah Dodson | |
| Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree | Brenda Lee | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Gwen Leahy | |
| Rose's Turn | Gypsy | Murder at the Bay Street Cabaret | Cami Nicole Hall | |
| Rose's Turn | Gypsy | The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Cami Nicole Hall | |
| Royals | Postmodern Jukebox | HSF Event | Drew Hillis | |
| Rude | Postmodern Jukebox | HSF Event | Chris Stanley | |
| Rude | Postmodern Jukebox | The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Chris Stanley | |
| Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer | Mistletoe Disco Band | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Justin P. Kent | Valerie America Lavelle |
| Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer | Mistletoe Disco Band | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Valerie America Lavelle | Justin P. Kent |
| Run, Run Rudolph | Kelly Clarkson | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Travis Cheeks | |
| S Wonderful | Shirley Bassey | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! | Dani Vazquez | |
| Santa Baby | Eartha Kitt | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! | Daniel Hilton/Sallie Just Sallie | |
| Santa Claus is Coming to Town | Mariah Carey | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Daniel J. Hilton/Sallie Just Sallie | |
| Say Something | Great Big World with Christina Aguilera | Love Stories/Love Songs | Hannah Dodson | Taylor |
| Say Something | Great Big World with Christina Aguilera | Love Stories/Love Songs | Taylor Mercier | Hannah |
| Schadenfreude | Avenue Q | Murder at the Bay Street Cabaret | Travis Coles | |
| Screw Loose | Cry Baby! | Bawdy Burlesque | Cecilia Tran Arango | |
| Send in the Clowns | A Little Night Music | Underground: Basement Broadway 1-17-23 | Damon Banks Jr. | |
| Separate Lives | Phil Collins & Marilyn Davis | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Carrie Kitchen | Damon Banks Jr. |
| Separate Lives | Phil Collins & Marilyn Davis | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Damon Banks Jr. | Carrie Kitchen |
| Seven Nation Army | Postmodern Jukebox | HSF Event | Cecilia Tran Arango | |
| Sexy | Mean Girls | Murder at the Bay Street Cabaret | Hannah Dodson | |
| She Used to Be Mine | Waitress | Showstoppers | Chris Stanley | |
| She Used to be Mine | Waitress | The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Taylor Mercier | |
| Shiver Me Timbers | Bette Midler | Underground: Bette Midler 1-31-23 | Rick Garman | |
| Silent Night | Justin Bieber | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Andrew Hillis | |
| Since U Been Gone | Postmodern Jukebox | HSF Event | Cami Nicole Hall | |
| Since U Been Gone | Postmodern Jukebox | The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Cami Nicole Hall | |
| Sincerely Me | Dear Evan Hansen | Award-Winnng Broadway | JoJo Ward/Carman iCandy | Treyla |
| Sincerely Me | Dear Evan Hansen | Award-Winnng Broadway | Trey Norris/Treyla Trash | Carman |
| Sing, Sing, Sing | Andrews Sisters | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! | Ensemble | |
| Skylark | Ella Fitzgerald | Underground: Standards 1-24-23 | Andrew Hillis | |
| Sleigh Ride | Ella Fitzgerald | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! | Travis Coles | Treyla |
| Sleigh Ride | Ella Fitzgerald | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! | Trey Norris/Treyla Trash | Travis Coles |
| Sleigh Ride | The Ronettes | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Hannah Dodson | Gwen Leahy |
| Sleigh Ride | The Ronettes | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Gwen Leahy | Hannah Dodson |
| Smile | Nat King Cole | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! | Trey Norris/Treyla Trash | |
| So Close | Jon McLaughlin | Love Stories/Love Songs | Kevin Hincapie/Christie Creme | |
| Some People | Bette Midler/Gypsy | Underground: Bette Midler 1-31-23 | Joey Timmons | |
| Somebody I Used to Know | Postmodern Jukebox | HSF Event | Gwen Leahy | |
| Someone Gets Hurt | Mean Girls | Underground: Basement Broadway 2-21-23 | Ethan Goble | |
| Someone to Watch Over Me | Linda Ronstadt | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! | Kevin Hincapie/Christie Creme | |
| Someone You Loved | Lewis Capaldi | Love Stories/Love Songs | Hannah Dodson | |
| Somethin' Stupid | Frank Sinatra & Nancy Sinatra | Underground: Rat Pack 2-28-23 | Justin P. Kent | Valerie America Lavelle |
| Somethin' Stupid | Frank Sinatra & Nancy Sinatra | Underground: Rat Pack 2-28-23 | Valerie America Lavelle | Justin P. Kent |
| Something's Coming | West Side Story | Underground: Basement Broadway 2-21-23 | Justin P. Kent | |
| Somewhere Over the Rainbow | Judy Garland | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! | Daniel Hilton/Sallie Just Sallie | |
| Somewhere That's Green | Little Shop of Horrors | Underground: Basement Broadway 2-21-23 | Valerie America Lavelle | |
| Special | Avenue Q | Bawdy Burlesque | Jordan Soto | |
| Stars and the Moon | Songs for a New World | Underground: Basement Broadway 2-21-23 | Taylor Mercier | |
| Stay With Me | Into the Woods | Underground: Basement Broadway 1-17-23 | Carrie Kitchen | |
| Stay With Me | Bette Midler | Underground: Bette Midler 1-31-23 | Joey Timmons | |
| Still Hurting | The Last Five Years | Underground: Basement Broadway 2-21-23 | Andrew Hillis | |
| Stormy Weather | Lena Horne | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! | Magnolia Minxxx | |
| Stuff Like That There | Bette Midler | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! | Trey Norris/Treyla Trash | |
| Suddenly Seymour | Little Shop of Horrors | Bawdy Burlesque | Daniel Hilton/Sallie Just Sallie | Gwen |
| Suddenly Seymour | Little Shop of Horrors | Bawdy Burlesque | Gwen Leahy | Daniel |
| Summer Nights | Grease | Award-Winnng Broadway | Ensemble | |
| Sway | Dean Martin | Underground: Rat Pack 2-28-23 | Justin P. Kent | |
| Take Me or Leave Me | Rent | Bawdy Burlesque | Gwen Leahy | Taylor |
| Take Me or Leave Me | Rent | Bawdy Burlesque | Taylor Mercier | Gwen |
| That's Amore | Dean Martin | Underground: Rat Pack 2-28-23 | Justin P. Kent | |
| That's Life | Frank Sinatra | Underground: Rat Pack 2-28-23 | Rick Garman | |
| The Christmas Song | Nat King Cole | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! | Ensemble | |
| The Christmas Song | Nat King Cole | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Ensemble | |
| The History of Wrong Guys | Kinky Boots | Award-Winnng Broadway | JoJo Ward/Carman iCandy | |
| The Internet is for Porn | Avenue Q | Showstoppers | Daniel Hilton/Sallie Just Sallie | Gwen |
| The Internet is for Porn | Avenue Q | Showstoppers | Gwen Leahy | Daniel |
| The Lady Is a Tramp | Shirley Bassey | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! | Daniel Hilton/Sallie Just Sallie | |
| The Rose | Bette Midler | Underground: Bette Midler 1-31-23 | Trey Norris | |
| The Song That Goes Like This | Spamalot | Underground: Basement Broadway 2-21-23 | Justin P. Kent | Valerie America Lavelle |
| The Song That Goes Like This | Spamalot | Underground: Basement Broadway 2-21-23 | Valerie America Lavelle | Justin P. Kent |
| The Way You Look Tonight | Tony Bennett | Love Stories/Love Songs | Taylor Mercier | |
| The Way You Look Tonight | Tony Bennett | Underground: Rat Pack 2-28-23 | Trey Norris | |
| Therapy | Tick Tick Boom | Underground: Basement Broadway 2-21-23 | Taylor Mercier | Trey Norris |
| Therapy | Tick Tick Boom | Underground: Basement Broadway 2-21-23 | Trey Norris | Taylor Mercier |
| There's No Business Like Show Business | Annie Get Your Gun | Murder at the Bay Street Cabaret | Ensemble | |
| Thinking Out Loud | Ed Sheeran | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Hannah Dodson | |
| This is Me | Greatest Showman | Say Gay | Taylor Mercier | |
| Those Were the Good Old Days | Damn Yankees | Murder at the Bay Street Cabaret | DJ Banks Jr. | |
| Time After Time | Eva Cassidy | Love Stories/Love Songs | Hannah Dodson | |
| Time After Time | Eva Cassidy | The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Hannah Dodson | |
| Time Warp | Rocky Horror Show | Showstoppers | Chris Stanley, Hannah Dodson, Gwen Leahy | Hannah and Gwen |
| Time Warp | Rocky Horror Show | Showstoppers | Gwen Leahy | Hannah and Chris |
| Time Warp | Rocky Horror Show | Showstoppers | Hannah Dodson | Gwen and Chris |
| To Keep My Love Alive | A Connecticut Yankee | Murder at the Bay Street Cabaret | Val Lavelle | |
| To Make You Feel My Love | Adele | Love Stories/Love Songs | Dani Vazquez | |
| Too Darned Hot | Kiss Me Kate | Hot Summer Broadway | Justin Kent | |
| Toxic | Postmodern Jukebox | HSF Event | Hannah Dodson | |
| True Colors | Cyndi Lauper (Choral Version) | Say Gay | Ensemble | |
| True Love | Pink | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Carrie Kitchen | |
| Two Ladies | Cabaret | Award-Winnng Broadway | Gwen Leahy | Travis Coles and Hannah |
| Two Ladies | Cabaret | Award-Winnng Broadway | Hannah Dodson | Gwen and Travis Coles |
| Two Ladies | Cabaret | Award-Winnng Broadway | Travis Coles | Gwen and Hannah |
| Underneath the Tree | Kelly Clarkson | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! | Hannah Dodson | |
| Unforgettable | Nat King Cole | Love Stories/Love Songs | Brandon Kaufman | |
| Unforgettable | Nat "King" Cole | Underground: Standards 1-24-23 | Travis Harold Coles | |
| Waiting for Life | On This Island | Bawdy Burlesque | Daniel Hilton/Sallie Just Sallie | |
| Wake Me Up (Acoustic) | Avicii | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Trey Norris | |
| Waving Through a Window | Dear Evan Hansen | Award-Winnng Broadway | Trey Norris/Treyla Trash | |
| We Are Family | Sister Sledge | Say Gay | Ensemble | |
| We Found Love (Acoustic) | Rihanna | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Taylor Mercier | |
| We Need a Little Christmas | Mame | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! | JoJo Ward/Carman iCandy | Richie |
| We Need a Little Christmas | Mame | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! | Richie Cook | Carman |
| What Christmas Means to Me | Stevie Wonder | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! | Chris Stanley, Travis Coles, Richie Cook, Justin P. Kent | Travis, Richie, and Justin |
| What Christmas Means to Me | Stevie Wonder | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! | Justin Kent | Chris, Richie, and Travis |
| What Christmas Means to Me | Stevie Wonder | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! | Richie Cook | Chris, Travis, and Justin |
| What Christmas Means to Me | Stevie Wonder | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! | Travis Coles | Chris, Richie, and Justin |
| What Do I Need with Love | Thoroughly Modern Millie | Hot Summer Broadway | Brandon Kaufman | |
| What I Did For Love | A Chorus Line | Murder at the Bay Street Cabaret | Ensemble | |
| Whatever Lola Wants | Damn Yankees | Murder at the Bay Street Cabaret | JoJo Ward/Carman iCandy | |
| When I Fall In Love | Nat King Cole | Love Stories/Love Songs | Daniel Hilton/Sallie Just Sallie | |
| When I'm Not Near | Finian's Rainbow | The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Justin P. Kent | |
| When I'm Not Near the One I Love | Finian's Rainbow | Bawdy Burlesque | Justin Kent | |
| When You're Good to Mama | Chicago | Bawdy Burlesque | JoJo Ward/Carman iCandy | |
| When You're Good to Mama | Chicago | The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Hannah Dodson | |
| White Christmas | The Drifters | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Justin P. Kent | Travis Coles, Travis Cheek |
| White Christmas | The Drifters | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Travis Harold Coles | Daniel/Sallie, Travis Cheek |
| White Christmas | The Drifters | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Travis Cheek | Daniel/Sallie, Travis Coles |
| Who'd I Be | Shrek: The Musical | Underground: Basement Broadway 2-21-23 | Taylor Mercier | |
| Why | Tick Tick Boom | Underground: Basement Broadway 1-17-23 | Trey Norris | |
| Wicked Little Town | Hedwig & the Angry Inch | Underground: Basement Broadway 2-21-23 | Trey Norris | |
| Wind Beneath My Wings | Bette Midler | Underground: Bette Midler 1-31-23 | Andrew Hillis | |
| Winter Wonderland | Michael Buble | Vivian & Bill's 1970s Christmas Party! | Travis Harold Coles | |
| Worse Things I Could Do | Grease | Underground: Basement Broadway 1-17-23 | Hannah Dodson | |
| You and Me | Lifehouse | Love Stories/Love Songs 2 | Daniel J. Hilton | |
| You Are the Reason | Calum Scott & Leona Lewis | Love Stories/Love Songs | Dani Vazquez, Kevin HIncapie | Kevin |
| You Are the Reason | Calum Scott & Leona Lewis | Love Stories/Love Songs | Kevin Hincapie/Christie Creme | Dani |
| You Can't Stop the Beat | Hairspray | Bawdy Burlesque | Ensemble | |
| You Could Drive a Person Crazy | Company | Award-Winnng Broadway | Dani Vazquez, Gwen Leahy, Hannah Dodson | Gwen and Hannah |
| You Could Drive a Person Crazy | Company | Award-Winnng Broadway | Gwen Leahy | Dani and Hannah |
| You Could Drive a Person Crazy | Company | Award-Winnng Broadway | Hannah Dodson | Gwen and Dani |
| You Could Drive a Person Crazy | Company | The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Hannah Dodson | Gwen, Dani |
| You Could Drive a Person Crazy | Company | The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Gwen Leahy | Hannah, Dani |
| You Could Drive a Person Crazy | Company | The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Dani Vazquez | Gwen, Hannah |
| You Don't Know Me | Ray Charles | Underground: Standards 1-24-23 | Rick Garman | |
| You Don't Own Me | Lesley Gore | Say Gay | Hannah Dodson | |
| You Give Love a Bad Name | Postmodern Jukebox | Time Traveling Drag Queens in the 1940s! | Dani Vazquez | |
| You Give Love a Bad Name | Postmodern Jukebox | HSF Event | Taylor Mercier | |
| You Give Love a Bad Name | Postmodern Jukebox | The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Dani Vazquez | |
| You Oughta Know | Jagged Little Pill | Murder at the Bay Street Cabaret | Hannah Dodson | |
| You Will Be Found | For Forever | Say Gay | Ensemble | |
| You'll Be Back | Hamilton | Award-Winnng Broadway | Travis Coles | |
| You'll Be Back | Hamilton | The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Travis Harold Coles | |
| You're a Mean One Mr. Grinch | Thurl Ravenscroft | Vivian & Bill's Christmas Party! | Justin Kent | |
| You're a Mean One, Mr. Grinch | Thurl Ravenscroft | The Best of the Bay Street Cabaret | Justin P. Kent | |
| You're Timeless to Me | Hairspray | Hot Summer Broadway | Brandon Kaufman, Treyla Trash | Treyla Trash |
| You're Timeless to Me | Hairspray | Hot Summer Broadway | Trey Norris/Treyla Trash | Brandon |
| Your Daddy's Son | Ragtime | Underground: Basement Broadway 1-17-23 | Damon Banks Jr. |